Fillet and Whipped Brie Sandwich

The Best Flavor Combination

This flavor combo is all about balance. The rich, meaty texture of the seared tuna brings umami and depth, which is perfectly offset by the brightness and acidity of the pickled cucumbers. The wasabi mayo adds just the right amount of creamy heat to wake up your taste buds without overpowering the fish, while the toasted brioche bun adds a hint of sweetness and a soft, buttery bite that ties it all together. Each element plays its part—contrast, complement, and texture—making this sandwich both satisfying and well-rounded.

Perfectly grilled fillet with a golden crust, finished over high heat on the Classic Joe® Series II grillClassic Joe® Series II grill with lid open.Fillet resting on a wooden board, garnished with herbs and grilled vegetables

Not All Cuts Are Created Equal

When it comes to grilling, a fillet might not have the fat of a ribeye, but it more than makes up for it with tenderness. That’s why it shines when treated right—indirect heat lets it cook evenly without drying out, and a final sear builds that savory, golden crust. Add a smoked compound butter or bold seasoning, and you’ve got a high-end flavor profile that’s surprisingly simple to pull off.

Two-Zone Cooking

One of the biggest advantages of the Classic Joe® Grill - Series II is its flexible grilling setup, and the Divide & Conquer® system makes that versatility effortless. Whether you're reverse-searing a thick cut of meat or juggling multiple ingredients with different cook times, this setup lets you grill smarter, not harder. Here’s how to get the most out of it:

  • Zone 1 – High Heat Sear: Position one half of the grate closer to the coals to create a direct heat zone—perfect for achieving that crusty, flavorful sear.
  • Zone 2 – Indirect Heat: Keep the other half raised or use a heat deflector to create a gentler cook zone—ideal for finishing proteins or cooking delicate veggies.
  • Mix & Match Grates: Use different cooking surfaces like cast iron or soapstone to match your cook style.
  • Stack for Space: Take advantage of the tiered rack system to cook multiple dishes at once without sacrificing control.
    With the right setup, you’re not just grilling—you’re orchestrating flavor.

Fillet and Whipped Brie Sandwich

Serves: 6 people
Skill:
Beginner:
Method:
Grilled
Food:
Beef

Ingredients

  • Main

Craving a delicious sandwich that’s both indulgent and impressive? This Fillet and Whipped Brie Sandwich is your perfect choice! Ideal for when you want a meal that’s quick, flavorful, and satisfying, this sandwich brings together tender fillet steak and creamy whipped brie in every bite. With a subtle balance of savory and creamy goodness, it’s a bite that will have everyone asking for the recipe. Whether it's for a casual lunch or a fun gathering, this sandwich is sure to steal the show!

Instructions

  1. 01

    Stabilize your grill at 450 F. Bank all the colas to one side of the fire box, top with wood chunk and place a grill grate on the lowest setting of the divide and conquer system. Cover the other half of the fire box a 1 halfmoon heat deflector and place the grill grate at the highest setting.

  2. 02

    Place the Brie (rind removed) on the indirect side for 2 minutes to pick up a bit of smoke. Remove and transfer to a food processor. Pulse to whip in air, the cheese should triple in volume. Once fully whipped, transfer to the refrigerator to cool a bit.

  3. 03

    Season fillet with Blackening seasoning and oil slightly then place on the direct side of the grill. Cook till rare to medium rare. (roughly 2 minutes on each side) Rest and slice into thin ribbons. Toss the sliced steak and arugula together and reserve.

  4. 04

    Butter large slices of sourdough and toast off on the direct side for a bit of char, transition to the indirect side to finish toasting.

  5. 05

    Transfer toasted bread to cutting board. Paint the toasted bread with smoked whipped brie, top with steak and arugula mixture, drizzle with honey and reduced balsamic, then finally top with parm flakes and enjoy!